HomeMy WebLinkAbout1997-03-11 - AGENDA REPORTS - YOUTH PROSENTATION (2)AGENDA REPORT
NEW BUSINESS
DATE: March 11, 1997
City Manager
Item to be pre:
Georae Caravalho
SUBJECT: RESOURCES FOR YOUTH PRESENTATION
DEPARTMENT: Parks, Recreation & Community Services
BACKGROUND
Violence in America is a major public health problem. In California, however, the extent of violence is
shocking. California is a national leader in homicide and suicide, with a majority of cases involving
firearms and youth.
The California Wellness Foundation is combating violence by allocating a substantial portion of grant
funds to address certain strategic initiatives, including "Violence Prevention," "Community Health
Population," "Health Improvement," "Teenage Pregnancy Prevention," and "Work and Health." The City
of Santa Clarita, the Win. S. Hart School District, Henry Mayo Memorial Hospital, North East Valley
Health Center, American Heart Association, Santa Clarita Child and Family Development Center, Santa
Clarita Valley Service Center, Newhall School District, and the Youth Alliance, are currently working
together to apply for funding from the California Wellness Foundation. Funding would support
"Wellness Villages," in which youth and adults will work together to identify health and environment
issues and solutions.
Attached to this report is a summary of information produced by Martin and Glantz through a grant from
the California Wellness Foundation, The California Wellness Foundation is an independent private
foundation created to improve the health of the people of California, funded through an endowment from
Health Net. The Martin and Glantz report explores the issue of youth violence, and proposes some first
steps in addressing violence issues.
RECOMMENDED ACTION
Take information into consideration for future program use.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Summary of Information from California Wellness Foundation - Strategies to Prevent
Youth Violence
B. Statistics
C. Youth At Risk article
2=0
Item:
Summary of Information
from California Wellness Foundation
Strategies to Prevent Youth Violence
1. 'It's time for an honest dialogue"
A. The issue of solutions to youth violence has become polarized and politicized.
1. Those who believe that we must teach young people sound values to
solve the problem are branded "heartless conservatives."
2. Those who talk about investing in prevention, and you are called a
"bleeding heart."
B. We must begin by accepting that youth violence affects all of us, and that it is
NOT inevitable.
2. 'Let's agree on the basics'
A. Young people need support before they get into trouble and become involved in
violence.
1. Incarceration only provides public safety after someone has been hurt.
2. In investment in prevention meabs fewer victims in our communities
and more productive young people contributing to society.
B. Public Safety is paramount.
1. The most violent young people need to be removed from society.
2. Public safety must also mean preventing violence and crime before it
happens.
C. Today's juvenile crime responses are inadequate.
L California spends more than $2.2 bilhon,a year on the juvenile justice
system.
2. The League of California Cities concluded in their 1995 report, The
Cost of Denial, that "it takes courage to admit that what weve been
doing for the last 20 years isn!t working. It's time for change.'
D. The public wants change.
1. In a statewide survey in May 1996 of 1,000 registered voters:
77% said they believed that prevention programs are effective
responses to juvenile violence
Only 17% said that building more detention facilities was the
answer.
More than 75% said they'd be willing to invest tax dollars to
fund prevention programs.
Most believe that families and local communities have the
greatest responsibility for preventing youth violence.
66% believe the rate of youth violence has increased over the
past few years.
+ 72% of voters believe that there is no age by which it is too late
to help a young person who has gotten involved in violent crime.
+ 71% felt that a mentoring program would be an effective
preventative measure; 61% believed in Beacon (or "second-shife
schools); 53% in conflict resolution training.
3. 'Let's take a closer look at the problem."
A. In many California counties, juvenile offenders arrested for such crimes as
petty theft or property damage are typically placed on probation, where they
are seen only once or twice by their probation officer.
B. California taxpayers spend roughly $32,000 per year to punish a young serious
offender.
C. A recent Rand Corporation study revealed that appropriate early
interventions would both rescue some youth from a life of crime, and save the
state money.
1. More than 150 crimes a year could be averted for every $1 million
invested in parenting programs. (NOTE. if half of those crimes would
have resulted injuvenile confinement, the state saves $2.4 million for
every $1 million invested --a net savings of $1.4 million, just by offering
parenting classes!)
2. About 258 crimes a year. could be averted for every $1 million spent on
programs that offer tutoring and offer modest financial incentives to
graduate from high school. (7f 112 of those crimes would have resulted
in incarceration, the state saves $4.1 million for every million invested)
3. An estimated 72 crimes a year could be prevented by investing $1
million annually in a program that closely monitors 12- and 13 -year old
delinquents.
D. The 1996-97 budget for the California Youth Authority is $361.4 million.
1. Approximately 68% of youth housed by the CYA are committed for
violent offenses.
2. 91% of CYA!s parolees are rearrested within 3 years.
E. This year's state budget allocated $11.6 million to fund a mentoring initiative
linking at -risk youth with responsible adults.
4. To engage in a productive and honest discussion of the issues, we need to start with facts.
A. Youth between the ages of 12 and 17 are crime victims five times more often
than people over the age of 35.
B. Every 17 hours another child in California is a murder victim. Homicide is the
leading cause of death for youth in California.
C. In 1995, there were 85,052 juvenile felony arrests in California; 26% of these
were for violent offenses.
D. State and local law enforcement agencies spend approximately $1.1 billion a
year to respond to juvenile crime and violence.
E. Total prosecution and public defense costs forjuvenile offenders are estimated
at $176 million annually.
F. The California court system spends an estimated $532 million each year to
process juvenile cases.
6.. One solution that works:
Beacon Necnnd-shift") Schools (Full-service programs)v
1. Youth ages 12-17 are more likely to be crime victims during the hours
of 3 to 11 p.m. than at any other time of the day. Younger children
(ages 6-11) are more likely to be victims at 3 p.m. than at any other
time of day.
2. Youth are more likely to commit crimes at 3 p.m. --when most schools
end classes for the day and dose their doors to students.
3. Full-service (Beacon, second -shift) schools offer programming before
and after school, often until late at night, including weekends,
vacations, and summers.
4. Full-service programs are broad in program design and may include
academic and computer classes, sports activities, job training, drama,
art and music classes, leadership and support groups, social services,
health care services and.clinics, parenting classes, and counseling.
5. Full-service programs are designed to include parents and members of
the community.
5VShaW&MI0gW.=
STATISTICS
"The most pressing problem we have in this state -- indeed, in this country, is our failure to
commit to the needs of children. We can talk about family values all we want, and set up more
committees, but I felt that with that approach we'd forever be picking around the edges of the
problem."
--Judge Alice Lytle.
Sacramento County Juvenile Court Judge
Every day in America, 16 children ages 19 and under are killed in gun homicides, suicides
and unintentional shootings. Many more are wounded.
.1.
.- Gunshot wounds are the second leading cause of death for all people aged 10-34
L. A. County kids, aged 19 and under, are more likely to die I a gun homicide or suicide than
in a motor vehicle crash.
A youth aged 10-19 committed suicide with a gun every six hours in 1991 -- 1,426 young
people in one year.
In 1992, firearm homicide was the number one cause of death for black men ages 15-34, and
the second leading cause of death for all 15-24 year olds.
A voung black male is 11 times more likelv to be murdered than avoune white male.
' For black males aired 15-19. firearm homicides have increased 158 Dercent from 1985-1993.
Youth violent crime amests rose 65% from 1990-1994. accordine to the F.B.I.
gn:agen3l lb.dm
ri
U'd ri
:-10
'4
More and more children are given no hope for the future.
A criminal -justice expert outlines the problems, analyzes promising
solutions, and proposes an eight -point plan to save youth at risk.
Growing numbers of children are being ne-
glected, abused, and ignored. Without change,
the dark specter of generational warfare could be-
come all too real.
After two decades of study, however, I conclude
that we can stop this negative trend and do a bet-
ter job of nourishing this most important resource.
To do otherwise would surely be a violation of our
obligation to future generations.
Child-care advocates claim that up to 15% of 16 -
to 19 -year-olds are at risk of never reaching their
potential and simply becoming lost in society.
Others would add to this category children of any
age if they are at risk of not becoming seIf-sup-
porting adults, headed for a life in institutions for
delinquency, crime, mental illness, ad-
diction, and dependency. We could also
describe as "at risk" those teens and preteens who
take on child rearing themselves and drop out of
school.
The task of saving these children has become in-
creasingly formidable. Compounding the problem
are the expanding gap between the rich and poor,
the increasing number of single -parent house-
holds, the rise of homes where both parents work,
the growing gun culture, and the recent increase
in negative attitudes about children, such as courts
that treat younger and younger children as adult
criminals.
As a result, children lose hope for the future. They
turn to peers for attention; they turn to guns for pro-
tection, security and status; and they turn to sex and
drugs for comfort and relief of boredom.
The gang too often becomes their "fam-
ily"—the only place where they re-
ceive attention and approval.
Criminologist James Fox of North-
eastern University predicts that the
murders committed by teenagers
(4,000 in the United States in 1995)
will skyrocket as the 39 million chil-
dren now under age 10 swell the
ranks of teenagers by 20% in the first
decade of the twenty-first century -
The result could be a juvenile crime
wave such as the United States has
neverseen.
Yet, such a catastrophe is not in-
evitable. There are some signs of
hope: a slightly decreased birth rate
among teenagers in the mid-1990s, a
rising bipartisan concern about "sav-
ing the children," burgeoning com-
munity-based experiments for meet-
ing the needs of youth,. and a
movement to regard poor prenatal
care, poor parenting skills, child
abuse, and child neglect as public-
health problems.
Beyond this, a striking change in
the rearing of children in many fami-
lies has been observed. Countering
the trend toward ignoring or even
abusing children is a trend toward
cherishing and nurturing them.
Thousands or even millions of
young parents are taking turns
working while the other stays at
home and makes child care almost a
full-time vocation. There is an un-
recognized renaissance in parenting
progressing quietly in neighbor-
hoods across the nation and possibly
the world.
Of course, having youth at risk is
not a problem unique to the United
States. Wars, social upheaval, rapidly
changing economic systems, political
instability, and cultural animosity
have placed millions of children at
risk around the world. Children die
of starvation while others wander
aimlessly in search of home and
family.
Singling out specific problems is
difficult, for most are interrelated.
For example, children left alone with-
out adult attention are more likely to
experiment with sex and drugs.
2 Youth At Risk
Teenagers who try drugs are
more likely to be involved in
delinquent behavior. Chil-
dren who experiment with
sex increase their likelihood
of becoming unmarried
teenage parents. Youngsters
who are physically and sexu-
ally abused are more likely to
adopt abusive behavior
toward others. Clearly, how-
ever, the following are major
factors in the dilemma.
Teenage Pregnancy
Many child advocates see
teenage pregnancy as the
main problem. Children hav-
ing children puts both gener-
ations at risk and often leads
to poverty, poor health care,
truancy, and underemploy-
ment. The dimensions of the
issue—as reported by the
National Commission on
Children, the United States
Census Bureau, and
others re staggering:
* Every year, one in 10
teenage females becomes
pregnant—more than 3,000 a
day.
a One of four teenage
mothers will have a second
child within one year of her
first child' bit,
s r .
Most teenage mothers
are single and receive no support
from the father.
* Eight of 10 teenage mothers do
not finish high school.
About one-fourth of the families in
America are headed by a single par-
ent—usually the mother. In the His-
panic community, it is one-third;
among black families, it is one-half.
Most of the children in these fairdlies
were bom to teenagers.
According to the Centers for Dis-
ease Control (CDC), 85% of all chil-
dren exhibiting behavioral disorders
come from fatherless homes. Other
statistical findings indicate that chil-
dren from fatherless homes are: 32
times more likely to run away, nine
times more likely to drop out of high
school; 14 times more likely to com-
mit rape; 10 times more likely to be
substance abusers; and 20 times
more likely to end up in prison.
Poverty
Whereas 75% of single -female -
headed households are in poverty at
least some of the time, and 33% are
chronically poor, poverty is also en-
demic to a majority of young house-
holds. Already, one in three children
under 6 lives below the poverty line.
About half of the homeless are
families with children. A million
divorces each year create new
female -headed households below
the poverty line.
Poor )iealth Care
CDC and other agencies have
found that at least 25 million chil-
dren in the United States have no
health care. This means that they are
taken to the hospital emergency
room or to nonprofessionals for
health problems. Without change in
Juvenile Arrests, igoa to 1994
150,000
125,000
100,000
75000
50,000
25,000
Arrests of persons aged 10-17
Total violent crimes IM Weapon law violations
0 Total drug abuse
Source: U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation, cited in Statistical Abstract of the United States
1996, Table 324.
health provider arrangements, half
of the nation's children could be
without health care by the year 2000.
Already, most unwed mothers re-
ceive no prenatal care.
Lack' of health care too often
equals stunted ability to learn, life -
altering health problems, lowered
ability to cope in a free-market sys-
tem, and, as a result, greater likeli-
hood of drug abuse, delinquency,
and crime.
Child Abuse
There is substantial evidence of
child abuse or neglect in the back-
ground of every known serial killer.
In most cases, the abuse was physi-
cally or sexually severe.
Beyond blatant abuse, neglect it-
self—ignoring the child's physical
and emotional needs—is a form of
abuse that scars the child as much or
more than beatings.
Child abuse and neglect are often
called the "silent epidemic" in the
United States. Alleged abuse more
than quadrupled between the mid-
1970s and the mid-1990s to more
than 3 million cases a year reported
(and 1 million substantiated). A
Gallup Poll reported that physical
abuse cases were 16 times greater
than reported rates, and sexual
abuse was 10 times greater.
The U.S. Department of Justice re-
ports that abused or neglected chil-
dren are 40% more likely to be ar-
Victimization Rates, 1994 (rate per 1,000 persons)
Age of All Crime MI Crimes Total Assault Rape,
Victim of Violence Sexual Assault
12-15 117.4 114.8 99.7 3.1
16-119
125.9 121.7 104.a 5.1
All
53.1 50.8 42.7 2.0
Source: U.S. Bureau of Justice Stafisff cs, cited In StatistkalAbstractof the United States 1996, Table 320.
I milli
N 11
nil
01
I [,,,,1I
W1
oil
Total violent crimes IM Weapon law violations
0 Total drug abuse
Source: U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation, cited in Statistical Abstract of the United States
1996, Table 324.
health provider arrangements, half
of the nation's children could be
without health care by the year 2000.
Already, most unwed mothers re-
ceive no prenatal care.
Lack' of health care too often
equals stunted ability to learn, life -
altering health problems, lowered
ability to cope in a free-market sys-
tem, and, as a result, greater likeli-
hood of drug abuse, delinquency,
and crime.
Child Abuse
There is substantial evidence of
child abuse or neglect in the back-
ground of every known serial killer.
In most cases, the abuse was physi-
cally or sexually severe.
Beyond blatant abuse, neglect it-
self—ignoring the child's physical
and emotional needs—is a form of
abuse that scars the child as much or
more than beatings.
Child abuse and neglect are often
called the "silent epidemic" in the
United States. Alleged abuse more
than quadrupled between the mid-
1970s and the mid-1990s to more
than 3 million cases a year reported
(and 1 million substantiated). A
Gallup Poll reported that physical
abuse cases were 16 times greater
than reported rates, and sexual
abuse was 10 times greater.
The U.S. Department of Justice re-
ports that abused or neglected chil-
dren are 40% more likely to be ar-
Victimization Rates, 1994 (rate per 1,000 persons)
Age of All Crime MI Crimes Total Assault Rape,
Victim of Violence Sexual Assault
12-15 117.4 114.8 99.7 3.1
16-119
125.9 121.7 104.a 5.1
All
53.1 50.8 42.7 2.0
Source: U.S. Bureau of Justice Stafisff cs, cited In StatistkalAbstractof the United States 1996, Table 320.
rested as juvenile delinquents and
adult criminals; three times as likely
to use drugs and alcohol, get into
fights, and deliberately damage
property; and four times as likely to
steal and be arrested. It is also re-
ported that one in eight neglected
children was later arrested for a vio-
lent offense.
Chronic Truancy
And School Dropout
On the average school day, as
many as 15% of junior and senior
high school students are not in
school. For too many, this is a Pat-
tern that leads to dropout.
Truants represent a large portion
of those arrested for daytime break-
ins and thefts, and dropouts are
over -represented in jails and prisons.
The Census Bureau reports that
earnings of students without a high
school diploma average far below
the poverty line.
Alcohol and Drug Abuse
Polls of youth indicate that nine
out of 10 teenagers drink alcohol to
some extent by the time they finish
high school, and a majority have
used illegal drugs. A study of 1,200
school dropouts in California found
their weekly alcohol -use rates were
twice as high as in -school counter-
parts, and their use of hard drugs
was two to five times as high.
Dropout drug users were much
more likely to be involved in violent
and criminal activities. One-third
said they had sold drugs in the past
year, and twice as many dropouts as
in -school students said they be-
longed to a gang.
Lark at Faith in Tomorrow
The Gallup Poll reported that 70%
of 16- to 24 -year-olds believe that the
world was a better place when their
parents were their age, and 56% said
it will be worse for their own chil-
dren. A joint Washington Post, Kaiser,
and Harvard survey reported that
the belief that "most people can be
trusted" fell from 54% to 33%, and
trust in government dropped from
76% to 25% over a three -decade pe-
riod ending in 1995. At -risk youth, in
particular, say they "live for today"
and see no hope for their future.
Youth At Risk 3
fST, ';r7&v
Crime and Homicide
In 1996, the Justice Department re-
ported that the juvenile homicide
rate had almost doubled in over a
decade, and blacks and males were
by far the most likely to be killed.
The major correlating factor was
an increase in the use of firearms.
Guns were also found to be the
single factor that could account for
tripling the number of juvenile
homicide offenders over the decade.
Justice predicts another doubling of
crime by juveniles by 2010 if current
trends continue.
Tragically, most victims of juvenile
violence are other juveniles, often
children who are not even involved
in the dispute.
Numerous programs have been
developed to cope with the at -
risk youth population. Here are
some of the best approaches.
Positive Reinforcement
Children crave attention more
than anything else, especially post-
tive attention. A baby who is cuddled,
talked to, and stimulated in the first
six weeks of life is much more likely
to be intelligent and well adjusted
than a baby ignored and simply fed
and cleaned up in silence. Later, the
child who is rewarded with praise
for accomplishments is much more
likely than others to become opti-
mistic and achievement oriented.
So how does one extinguish un-
acceptable behavior? By ignoring it
and efinninating the child's ability to
gain attention. The simplest ex-
amples are having the child sit in a
corner or placing the child in a
closed room for a short "time out."
For older children, pats on the
back, awards, and ceremonies to cel-
ebrate accomplishments are particu-
larly effective in fostering prosocial
behavior and giving at -risk youth a
stake in society, helping them over-
come lack of hope and lack of faith
in the future. The bottom line: Using
positive reinforcement must become
a way of life for parents, teachers,
and others.
4 Ybuth at Risk
Parent Education
Teaching positive
reinforcement to
prospective parents
has been effective in
reducing the at -risk
population. Parent
education can pro-
vide information and
skills to assist the
parent -to -be with in-
centives to learn and
use good child-rear-
ing practices.
To be effective in re-
ducing teenage par-
enting, these classes
must reach children
early—sixth grade or
shortly thereafter. In
programs that force
them to carry a com-
putmized aying and
wetting doll around.
for a couple of weeks,
many teenagers de-
cide to - postpone
parenthood.
Healthy Start
e Jus ce Depart-
ment and Health and
Human Services each
have Healthy Start
programs. Justice's
program was de-
signed to reduce ne-
glect and abuse,
while the Health and Human Ser-
vices program was designed to re-
duce infant mortality by strengthen-
ing the maternal and infant care
systems at the community level.
A similar program, Healthy Fan -d -
lies America, was launched in 1992
by the National Committee to Pre-
vent Child Abuse to help establish
home visitation programs, service
networks, and funding opportunities
so all new parents can receive the
necessary education and support.
A child revels in the ride and attention offered by a Boys &
Girls Clubs of America staff member- These Clubs are among
several successful programs addressing the problems of
youth at risk, says author Stephens.
Mentoring
To help provide -positive adult
role models for at -risk youths, lead-
ers in Kansas City are on a quest to
recruit, train, and assign 30,000
mentors—one for every at -risk child
in the city. Other communities have
greatly expanded existing mentor-
ing programs, such as Big Brothers
and Big Sisters.
Nonviolent Conflict
Resolution
Programs are now appearing in
schools and community centers to
provide attitudes and skills neces-
sary to resolve conflict nonviolently.
Models have been developed by the
American Bar Association and the
Justice Department, as well as by ed-
ucators. One of the best models in-
volves training school staff—teach-
ers, administrators, custodians, bus
drivers, and cafeteria workers—in
creative nonviolent conflict -resolu-
tion methods. Older students are
also taught these techniques, and
they in turn teach younger students,
turning peer prmure into a positive
rather than negative force.
Community Schools Programs
All communities have schools, but
all communities do not use those
schools effectively in breaking the
cycle of violence and frustration
among at -risk youth. A federal ini-
tiative—the Community Schools
Program—has been effective in rally-
ing the community around the
school.
Other examples of successful part-
nerships include:
* In Missouri, 6,000 volunteers
keep 675 schools open for extra
hours.
- Boys' and Girls' Clubs offer
mentoring in New Jersey schools.
- In New York City, Safe Haven
programs provide safe environments
and positive after-school tutoring
and enrichment programs.
*Year-round schools in many
communities facilitate better learn-
ing—since students no longer have
the long summer to forget what they
leamed—and foster more opportuni-
ties for extracurricular programs,
from tutoring and mentoring to fam-
ily activities and counseling.
Character Education
Character education in schools
generally revolves around univer-
sally accepted values (e.g., love,
truthfulness, fairness, tolerance, re-
sponsibility) that find little opposi-
tion based on differing political, so-
cial, and religious beliefs. Schools
with large numbers of at -risk chil-
dren have reported pregnancy and
dropout rates cut in half, along with
reduced fights and suspensions, af-
ter character education took hold.
Youth Initiatives
Surveys by Gallup Poll, Wirthlin
Group, and others consistently find
that 95% of teenagers believe it is im-
portant for adults and teens "to get
involved in local civic, charitable,
cultural, environmental, and politi-
cal activities." More than three-
fourths of teens say they are already
participating in some volunteer
work, such as working at soup
kitchens for the poor, nursing homes
for the elderly, or shelters for the
homeless.
Programs such as Americorps, Job
Corps, Peace Corps, and others pro -
To Help Youth, Should
Easy Divorce Be Stopped?
If society were truly interested
in looking out for children's fu-
tures, it would put an end to easy
divorces, claims William A.
Galston, former assistant to Presi-
dent Clinton for domestic policy.
"Since the 1960s, the number of
children directly touched by di-
vorce has jumped from 485,000 to
one million a year" in the United
States, writes Galston in The
American Enterprise.
Except in households where
parents are abusivei most children
fare better when marriages are
maintained.
"Divorces in nonabusive cases
have a negative effect on children
in a number of key areas: school
performance; psychological ill-
ness; crime, suicide, out -of -wed-
lock births; adult work perform-
ance; and the propensity to
become divorced," Galston ar-
gues. "There is also evidence that
Future Possibilities
For Controlling Risk
Technology is beginning to of-
fer several other possibilities to
reduce the problems of at -risk
youth, though some of these pos-
sibilities may offend many
people's concept of justice and
humanity,
For example, new birth -control
devices could be implanted in all
youth or all at -risk youth. Al-
ready, courts have ordered women
to either have five-year birth -
control implants or face prison for
child abuse.
Another possibility is to im-
plant body -functioning monitors
and control devices, which may
the experience of divorce dimin-
ishes trust in people and institu-
tions, and impedes the capacity of
individuals to form stable, lasting
relationships."
Galston blames these problems
on the ease with which divorces
have become attainable through
no-fault laws and other policies.
Marriage—and its dissolution—
ha * s become focused on the per-
sonal happiness of adults rather
than on the nurturing and devel-
opment of children.
To turn the focus back toward
the well-being of children,
Galston recommends increasing
pre -marriage education (perhaps
taking the place of sex education
in schools), reorienting economic
and social policies to create a
"marriage -friendly environment,"
and rescinding no-fault divorce
laws for couples with minor
children.
Source: "Braking Divorce for the Sake of
Children' by William A. Galston, The
American Enterprise (May/June 1996).
be developed as early as the first
decade of the twenty-first cen-
tury. These very small computer -
controlled machines would be im-
planted in the body to monitor all
systems and add or subtract
chemicals and hormones, slow
down or speed up electrical
synapses, and correct genetic ab-
normalities. The monitor could
thus control behavior and elimi-
nate most delinquent and crimi-
nal actions.
The question raised for society
is whether these controls would
be used only on criminals, or also
on at -risk youth (potential crimi-
nals), or on anyone at all.
--Gene Stephens
Youth at Risk 5
Playing ball at a Boys & Giris Club. Youth
athletic leagues are among the community -
oriented programs recommended by author
Stephens to prevent problems of at-rJsk
youth.
vide young people a chance to learn
the joy of giving to others; at the
same time, it gives them a stake in
society by developing skills, disci-
pline, and a chance to go to trade
school or college through grants and
loans. Many communities and even
some states (Georgia, for example)
are developing youth -oriented com-
munity service programs of their
own.
Community Policing
Law enforcement programs are in-
creasingly working in partnership
with the community to identify
crime -breeding problems and imple-
ment solutions. Many of the at -risk
youths' problems thus become com-
munity problems and lend them-
selves to community solutions.
Homelessness, poverty, lack of posi-
tive adult role models, and poor
health care may lead to safe shelters,
community assistance, mentors, and
in -school or community clinics.
One of the best examples of this
approach took place in Milton
Keynes, England, which faced a rash
of shoplifting, burglary, and a few
store robberies. Rather than seek out,
arrest, and prosecute the young of-
fenders, Police Commander Caroline
Nicholl instituted a series of confer-
ences in which police, merchants,
and neighbors met with offenders
and suspects to identify reasons for
the offenses. As a result, Nicholl
says, "We learned about child abuse,
bullying, alcoholism, and many
other problems, and the community
set to work on these."
Restorative Justice
Most at -risk youth encounter the
justice system early in life. Where ju-
venile justice once focused on the
needs of the child, it now focuses on
the deeds of the child and a belief that
someone, adult or child, has to pay
for the offense.
Countering this trend is a restora-
tive justice movement, which holds
6 Youth at Plisk
BOYS 6 GIRLS CLUBS Cf AMERICA
that the purpose of justice is to bring
peace and harmony back to the com-
munity by restoring victim, commu-
nity, and offender to a symbiotic re-
lationship. Often, restoring includes
restitution, service, and reclamation.
In the case of juvenile offenders,
the child usually makes restitution to
the victim either by his or her own
earnings or through closely moni-
tored personal service (cutting the
lawn, raking leaves, chopping wood,
or making home repairs), several
hours of service to the community,
an apology to the victim, counseling,
and essays and/or school talks on
the harm the offense does to society
Once the restitution is completed,
the child's record is purged.
There are literally hundreds of
programs being tried in small and
large communities across the nation
and, indeed, worldwide.
The plan that follows represents a
consensus from groups to whom
I've given the same assignment over
the past decade: "Develop a program
So,
t/ -k :
to turn your communitys youth into
productive, happy, law-abiding
adults." These groups have included
students from high school to gradu-
ate school, practitioners from police
to social service workers, and com-
munity leaders, all participating in
brainstorming and planning sessions
to alleviate the youth -at -risk problem.
Here is a comprehensive plan
based on my 10 -plus years' experi-
ence with these exercises.
1. Commit to positive reinforce-
ment through community and
school-based parenting classes
(mandatory in schools), ongoing me-
dia campaigns, positive attention,
and recognition in all schools
(preschool through high school) and
community-based programs.
2. Promote nonviolent conflict
resolution among peers through
mandatory educational programs for
students, parents, teachers, coun-
selors, administrators, media, and
community campaigns. I
3. Encourage mentoring for all
children. Civic, business, and com-
munity campaigns should recruit
and train mentors, matching them
by needs and temperament. Pro-
grams such as Big Brothers and Big
Skters �11011]d lie e\panded.
4. Establish community—school
partnerships to offer before- and af-
ter-SChool tutoring. Enlist votith to
perform er% ices to the community
to eoll,111CO their stake in societ��
5. Develop community -oriented
proactive policing pro grams that
begin with a philo�oph.� of pre�en-
tion. Examples of prevention pro -
,,rams include midnight basketball
leagues, police—youth athletic leagues,
neighborhood housing project sub-
stations, and foot patrols. These all
involve partnerships of police, par-
ents, church, business, civic, and
community organizations.
6. Initiate ethical and cultural
awareness programs that build on
partnerships among family, church,
1 The Youth Corps
I: Solution
A wide variety of programs
and proposals seek to improve the
futures of youth at risk.
In Washington, D.C., the U.S.
Corporation for National Service
coordinates 120 youth corps pro-
grams in 37 states. These pro-
grams, now involving 22,000
young people, combine work ex-
perience and education within the
context of community servi . ce,
The programs are funded by fed-
eral, state, and local governments,
foundations, and corporations. In
addition, the programs are com-
pensated under fee-for-service
contracts.
Besides teaching skills and pro-
viding a benefit to the public, the
programs try to instill a work
ethic in participants and help
them to understand the meaning
of working with others toward a
common goal.
The youth corps program is a
cost effective.way to help young
people earn more, work more,
and steer away from trouble, ac-
cording to a recent study by Abt
school, media, civic, business, and
other community groups. These pro-
grams w0nld �n`iphasize finding
common ground on basic values,
such as respect, responsibilitv, and
restraint.
7. Design youth opportunity pro-
grams to provide all children the
chance to reach their potential, re-
Prdless of circumstances. Such pro-
grams could be run through school,
business, and community partner-
ships that provide in -school jobs and
child care, career counseling and
training, opportunity scholarships,
and recognition for achievement.
8. Set up peer counseling hotlines
to help youth help each other through
the trying times of adolescence.
To this basic plan we may also
Associates for the Corporation for
National Service. Among other
results, the study found that par-
ticipation in the corps reduced in-
cidence of unwanted pregnancies
among African-American women
and increased the likelihood of
Hispanic women to work and ex-
press a desire to obtain a college
degree.
Youth corps' impacts were found
to be especially positive for young
black men, who obtained more
work and higher earnings and in-
creased both their educational as-
pirations and civic participation.
"Given the widespread percep-
tion that 'nothing works' to posi-
tively influence the life chances
of disadvantaged youth, it is es-
pecially important to be able to
document the benefits of pro-
grams like youth corps," says
JoAnn Jastrzab, director of the
study.
Sources: The Corporation for National
Service, 1201 New York Avenue, N.W.,
Washington, D.C. 20525. Telephone
202/606-5000.
Abt Associates. Inc., 55 Wheeler
Street, Cambridge, Massachusetts
02138. Telephone 617/492-7100; fax
617/492-5219.
consider in the future adding
,, more
dramatic (though often controver-
sial) measures, such as birtli-control
implants, health monitoring and
treatment implants, behavioral con-
trol implants in extreme cases, com-
puter-assisted brain implants, and
educational implants. But these mea -
sores should only be considered af-
ter reaching consensus concerning
ethical issues.
In addition, we must focus on jus-
tice wherL delinquency and crime
occur. Youth offenders must recog-
nize the consequences of their ac-
tions on the victim, the victim's family,
and the community. The harm must
be ameliorated and restored through
mediation and arbitration, restitution,
service to the victim and community,
reclamation, and reconciliation.
Final Thoughts
Every community can develop
programs guided by this model. But
all plans must adopt certain guiding
principles that permeate the ap-
proac .
Children want attention above
everything. Thus, giving attention
reinforces behavior and denying at-
tention extinguishes behavior. Both
praise and punishment are attention,
and both will reinforce behavior that
gets that attention.
It is important to instill optimism
and faith in the future in all children,
as they are the key to success. The
very nature of adolescence is to chal-
lenge authority, but most children
drift through this troubled period
and become law-abiding adults un-
less they become labeled as delin-
quents, criminals, or losers.
Surely we can see the need to
reach out and lend a hand to the
world's most precious resource. 1:1
About the Author
Gene Stephens is a profes-
sor in the College of Crimi-
not Justice, University of
South Carolina, Columbia,
South Carolina 29208. Tele-
phone 803f777-7315; tax
803/777-9600. He is the
criminal -justice editor ofTHE FU7URlST;
his last article, "Crime in Cylberspace: The
Digital Underworld," appeared in the
September -October 1995 issue,
Youth at Risk 7
_T1